Gov. Tina Kotek wants Oregon lawmakers to ban new immigration detention centers in the state.

Kotek made the call at a Nov. 7 press conference, as first reported by the Oregon Capital Chronicle. But federal courts have struck down similar laws in other states, raising questions about whether such a ban could survive a legal challenge.

"I would like to see a bill that we can have here in Oregon to never allow detention facilities in the state of Oregon," Kotek told reporters. "We don't have one now. I don't think we should have them."

The push carries weight for Salem residents. In an Oct. 12 statement from the governor's office, Kotek cited at least 45 ICE detentions since Oct. 6. That statement also said ICE had arrived at a NORPAC fruit and vegetable processing facility in Brooks and used tear gas in a Salem residential neighborhood.

Oregon's existing law may not hold up

Oregon already bans private immigration detention centers under a 2021 state law. State law has also prohibited local and state governments from participating in immigration enforcement without a court order for decades.

Oregon is one of a few states without an overnight, large-scale immigration detention facility. The state has processing facilities in cities such as Portland, where detainees are temporarily held and then released or transported to long-term detention in Tacoma, Washington, the Capital Chronicle reported.

New legislation could try to expand the 2021 ban by changing how state-run public services such as utilities or permits are granted for detention projects. But federal courts have already struck down state laws banning private immigration detention centers.

The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled in 2022 that a California ban was unconstitutional. The court found it violated the U.S. Constitution's supremacy clause, which prevents states from impeding federal operations. The 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals in 2025 struck down a New Jersey law banning private prison companies from contracting with federal immigration authorities to operate detention centers.

Tung Yin, a law professor at Lewis & Clark Law School in Portland, told the Capital Chronicle he does not see any way the proposal could survive a federal challenge. Yin noted that federal courts have blocked state laws on less central issues, such as requiring federal agents to show their faces, and said a detention-center ban would be even less likely to hold up.

Newport settlement leaves gap

Kotek's call follows an October settlement in a lawsuit Oregon filed against the federal government over a proposed ICE facility at the U.S. Coast Guard site at Newport's municipal airport.

In a statement announcing the settlement, Attorney General Dan Rayfield said ICE confirmed it has no current plans to build detention centers in Newport or anywhere in Oregon. ICE also agreed to provide prior notice if it resumes plans to open a facility in Newport. The Capital Chronicle reported the agreement requires at least 30 days of notice before environmental permitting begins, but the requirement is limited to Newport and expires in August 2027.

State Rep. David Gomberg, D-Otis, told the Capital Chronicle the settlement "leaves the door wide open" for future detention centers after the agreement expires. He said he is in early conversations with lawmakers about legislation to close that gap.

A U.S. Department of Homeland Security spokesperson said the agency has no new facilities to announce "at this time." The spokesperson also argued that the Constitution's supremacy clause prevents state officials from controlling federal law enforcement.

The legal odds are steep. Kotek's office declined to provide details about what specific legislation she wants to see. The Oregon Legislature's next session begins in 2027.